Easing the Legalese with Hispanic Workers
Wondering if you are within your legal bounds with overtime or what the government might do to you regarding the legal status of your Hispanic workers? Before despair starts burrowing into your mind and furrowing your brow, find out what actions an industry attorney advises on dealing with some of the most-common challenges facing greenhouse employers.
In surveying the ethnic origins of your greenhouse
employees, it probably comes as no surprise that one in eight people in the
United States is of Hispanic origin, or 32.8 million, according to a 2000 U.S.
Census Bureau report. Approximately 66.1 percent of this population comes from
Mexico, where poverty levels are high and the promise of a better life lies
just across the border. Mexicans and other Hispanics are industrious,
nose-to-the-grindstone people who complain very little, and are spurred on by a
deep sense of optimism that working in the United States will improve their own
lives and those of their families. Your Hispanic employees are probably some of
the best workers you've ever had -- and some of them may be in this country
You may have invested many years of training in one or more
of these individuals, earning their trust and loyalty, and allowing them to
rise into important production positions in which they've carved a niche that
you would be hard-pressed to find a replacement for. Despite your best efforts
to conduct your business according to the law, however, there will always be
factors out of your control. For example, you may be one of 750,000 recipients
of a letter from the Social Security Administration (SSA) advising employers of
mismatched Social Security numbers (SSN), and some of your most valued
employees could be on this list.
James Huse, Jr., inspector general of the SSA, gave a
testimony before the House Judiciary Subcommittee on June 25, 2002, regarding
Social Security integrity and its importance in homeland security. He indicated
that the undocumented population in the United States reached five million in
1996 and increases by approximately 275,000 people every year; many of these
people have obtained SSNs fraudulently. The agricultural industry in particular
appears to be under the microscope due to the disproportionately high number of
employee mismatches within the industry. "SSA statistics show three
industries (agriculture, food and beverage, and services) account for almost
one-half of all wage items in SSA's Earnings Suspense file (ESF) for which
employee names and SSNs fail to match SSA's records. Of these industries,
agriculture is the largest contributor, representing about 17 percent of all
ESP items. In fact, in one study of 20 agriculture employers, we determined
that six of every 10 wage reports submitted by these employers had incorrect
names or SSNs," said Huse in his testimony.
According to Fred Atterbury, legal consultant to the
American Nursery & Landscape Association (ANLA) and others in the green
industry on wage and hour, I-9 forms and related matters, there are four basic
issues on his most-frequently-asked questions list by green industry members
with Hispanic employees. Mismatched Social Security number issues top the list.
The second most-common question has to do with employers discovering they have
an illegal employee and wanting to know how to approach obtaining legal status
for that employee. I-9 Form questions come in third, and fourth are wage and
hour issues such as making deductions and overtime.
Social Security mismatches
The SSA's form letter, which you may or may not have
received, begins with an explanation as to why you have received the letter.
"We are sending you this letter because some of the names and Social
Security numbers that you reported on the Wage and Tax Statements (Forms W-2)
for tax year 2001 don't agree with Social Security Administration records,"
it reads. "We need corrected information from you so that we can properly
credit your employees' earnings. We realize there could be a number of reasons
why the reported information doesn't agree with ours, such as: transcription or
typographical errors, incomplete or blank name or SSN, or name changes."
The letter proceeds to inform the recipients that they have 60 days to respond
with the information they are able to correct; materials are attached to
instruct the recipient on how to correct SSNs.
Despite the fact that directions are clearly spelled out and
there is even a phone number to call for questions, employers start worrying
about what they should do, at which point they call law firms like Atterbury's.
"It's the first time they get 'official' notification from any
governmental agency that they may have a potential immigration problem,"
says Atterbury. "As soon as they get that letter, they start worrying
about the potential ramifications." All of the information you need,
however, is contained within this letter; an attorney can only direct the
letter recipient back to the instructions delineated in the letter. The reason
greenhouse managers and owners are calling, according to Atterbury, is that
they want to protect themselves. "Many of them have heard these horror
stories about the immigration service backing up buses and loading all of their
workers on it and hauling them away, and they Á don't want that to
happen to them." Employers are also concerned because they may have
received the Social Security letter for a long-time employee. "It is not
unheard of that an employee noted in the letter may have been an employee for
five or six years. They've got a reputation and some work experience with that
individual, they might even be a key person -- an assistant foreman or
something, and that would be difficult to replace in today's workforce."
Following the instructions in the letter is the easy part;
what's muddier is what you should do in the long-term. There are a number of
possibilities that will vary based on you, the employer, and what you view as
the best way to proceed. Depending on what you find out about the mismatch,
you'll have to ask yourself if firing the employee is the best option, asking
the employee to visit the Social Security office themselves, or perhaps not
even apprising the employee of a potential problem and taking action on your
own. You don't have to assume the worst has occurred right away, however;
remember that the error could be a clerical mistake on your part or the government's
involving transposed numbers or misspelled names.
Before making any drastic decisions, comb through the
letter's instructions. If your records do not match the W-2 Form, you should
correct the Form and report that correction to the SSA. In this case, the
employee doesn't even have to be involved. If your records and the W-2 Form do
match, however, you should "ask your employee to check his/her Social
Security card and to inform you of any name or SSN difference between your
records and his/her card. If your employment records are incorrect, correct
your records." If your records and the employee's records match, however,
the employee needs to resolve the issue with SSA and inform you of any changes,
and you should then correct your own records. ANLA's Government Relations Team
advises that employers give employees a reasonable amount of time to resolve
the mismatch issue with SSA and report back to the employer if there are
changes that need to be made. The mismatch letter, the SSA writes, "is not
a basis 'in and of itself' for you to take any adverse action against the
employee, such as laying off, suspending, firing or discriminating against an
individual who appears on the list." Employers who use the information in
the letter to justify taking adverse action against an employee may violate
state or federal law and be subject to legal consequences.
Seeking legal status
Not all employers would seek to terminate an employee they
believed to have questionable immigration status, anyway; for some, discovering
or knowing that an employee is illegal, especially if that employee is a great
asset to the company, is reason to find out how they can make the employee
right with the law. Says Atterbury, "An employer calls and says, 'I have
reason to believe that some of my workers are not legal. What can I do to get
them legal?'" This issue may have arisen because employees in question
have come forward and admitted that they are not legal, or because another
worker has come forward and indicated that the employer should take a look at X
employee's documents because he/she may be illegal. If the employer finds out
an employee is illegal, they will either terminate them or call an attorney to
find out how they can make the employee legal.
Unfortunately, there is no one way to answer this question
-- it must be dealt with on a case-by-case basis. Atterbury usually advises
employers to go to a local attorney who handles immigration issues, and more
specifically, one who deals with immigration issues in the green industry. You
can find one through a referral from a corporate attorney, or contact the
American Bar Association (www.abanet.org) for references. "Either the
employer themselves and/or the employer and employee have to go and discuss it
with the immigration attorney and determine what their individual legal status
is, and what they can do to amend their status, if it is illegal, to make it
legal," Atterbury says.
An alternative, not-so-safe approach is for both employer
and employee to go to the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) in
person and ask what procedures would need to be followed to legalize the
employee. You could be voluntarily placing your employee in the arms of danger,
however, judging from the recent uproar over what happened to a number of
Middle Eastern immigrants when they were forced to register with the INS. For
those unfamiliar with the story, all male visitors aged 16 and older from five
countries, including Iran, Iraq, Libya, Sudan and Syria, were ordered to
register with the INS by December 16, and in the process, some were arrested
for not having their papers in order. In some cases, this lack of proper
documentation was caused by government backlog. Lawsuits have been filed
contending the INS is violating Congress' intent by detaining so many
immigrants when the order was simply to register them.
With an attorney, you can be assured confidentiality and a
possible path, however long, to legality; with the INS, no one knows what may
One tool every employer has in place to both avoid penalties
and hiring potentially illegal employees is the I-9 Form. I-9 Forms are
required by every employer in the United States for every employee hired since
November 1986. The Á Form performs two functions: First, it identifies
the workers and verifies their ability to work in this country, and second, if
a government agent visits your facility, it provides documentation for them to
verify the correctness of their own files and see if there are any potential
violations of the law. There are fines and penalties associated with filling
these forms out incorrectly or not filling them out at all, accepting illegal
documents, or filling them out but providing incorrect documentation. Social
Security cards are often one of the documents presented by a worker when
filling out an I-9 Form, which brings us full-circle to the issue of Social
Security mismatches once again.
So what happens if you accept documents that, unbeknownst to
you, turn out to be fraudulent? "As long as the employer examined the
documents and they appeared to be valid using a reasonable-person test -- as
long as they look valid on the face of them -- that's as far as the employer
needs to go. There is no penalty to the employer in those circumstances,
assuming they followed a good-faith effort in examining them," Atterbury
And what if you know an employee is illegal and try to skirt
the law by not filling out an I-9 and paying "under the table?" First
of all, Atterbury does not believe that hiring illegal workers is as bad a
problem as it used to be. "Business has become more sophisticated and the
government has become more sophisticated, in terms of the tracking of workers
and payment of wages." If you should get caught, however, you could face
large fines and penalties from the INS, the Internal Revenue Service, the SSA
and any other agency that has anything to do with employment issues.
Wage and Hour Issues
The fourth issue concerning greenhouse employers has not to
do directly with immigration, but with wage and hour laws. Making deductions
that would reduce the employee's wage below minimum is a frequent problem about
which employers seek guidance. For example, the federal minimum wage is
currently $5.15 per hour. If an employer hires someone at $6.00 per hour but
requires the employee to purchase a uniform for the job, the employer would be
violating the Wage and Hour Law if buying that uniform reduced the employee's
pay below $5.15 in any given workweek.
Overtime issues are another area of concern, according to
Atterbury, since it is widely assumed that employees working in the green
industry are exempt from overtime because they are working in agriculture. That
is not necessarily so. "The government's definition of agriculture isn't
quite that broad, it's a bit more restrictive, and there are a number of
employers that don't qualify for the agriculture exemption under the Fair Labor
Standards Act. Overtime would be required if the employer does not qualify for
the agriculture exemption; the standard is that overtime is required. You start
with the basic premise that overtime is required to determine if employees are
exempt or not."
Employers will frequently call wanting to know if they might
be violating the Wage and Hour Law by not paying overtime. Labor laws can be
complicated, and it is difficult to determine a simple yes or no answer for
particular questions without scrutinizing the case at hand. Atterbury advises
that an employer with questions that fall under the Wage and Hour Law contact
an attorney specializing in two things: first, the Fair Labor Standards Act,
and second, its application in the green industry. "Even an attorney
that's familiar with the Fair Labor Standards Act may not do much work in the
green industry, and it's a bit different than, say, working in a factory or car
dealership or something."
ANLA offers a publication to its members that summarizes the
Fair Labor Standards Act and its application in the green industry, written by
Atterbury. For more information, call (202) 789-2900. If you have been
contacted by the SSA, read the documents, follow their instructions and relax.
If you want to make sure you aren't violating any laws under the Fair Labor
Standards Act, call an attorney with experience in the green industry. Wisdom
for how to proceed can only come when all facts lie before you -- not in the
quagmire of the unknown.