Improving Labor Efficiency
Every grower can find ways to reduce labor costs. A career of extension work has taught John Bartok some of the best.
Everyone strives for labor efficiency, whether operating a
greenhouse alone or with the help of many employees. A good starting point in
evaluating labor efficiency is to collect data on which operations require the
greatest amount of time. Transplanting, hand watering, plant selection for
shipping and moving plants into and out of the growing area often use excessive
labor. Evaluate these first to see if improvements can be made.
Equipment is available for almost all the tasks that take
place in the greenhouse, but not all tasks should be mechanized. This is
especially the case for the small grower because the initial capital outlay on
some of this equipment is very high.
Before purchasing equipment or making changes to an existing
system, consider the following basic concepts that apply to all businesses:
Keep things simple.
Equipment or systems that you and your employees understand work best. These
generally have fewer adjustments that need to be made, require less maintenance
and use standard parts.
Analyze your needs thoroughly.
style='font-weight:normal'>Equipment is expensive to own. Consider your
resources and what will give the greatest return to your business. For example,
an automatic watering system that can be used year-round may be a better choice
than a precision seeder if you use it only 10 days a year.
Mechanize jobs that are repetitive, tedious or
time-consuming. Considerable equipment has
been developed for most of these jobs. Filling containers, spacing and moving
plants, and watering are good examples of repetitive tasks that make sense to
Install equipment that reduces peak-period labor
requirements. The spring season and
holiday shipping periods are usually the busiest. Carts or conveyors will move
plants quicker than hand carrying. You also reduce the need to hire and manage
Select equipment that will pace workers.
style='font-weight:normal'>Conveyor belts work well for potting, transplanting
and packaging, providing uniformity and consistency. A variable-speed motor
adjusts the belt speed for different operations.
Reduce the amount of walking that employees do.
style='font-weight:normal'> Walking adds considerable time to the cost of
plants. An average time to pick up or set down a flat of plants is 1.5 seconds.
Carrying or walking can be figured at four feet per second. At an $8 per hour
labor rate, making a round-trip 15 feet away to place a flat of plants on a
bench adds about 2 cents to its cost.
Standardize your operations. Keep the number and types of containers that are used to a minimum to
reduce inventory and the time needed to make changes to equipment. Where
possible, ship in standard units such as carts or pallets.
Consider alternatives to purchasing equipment.
style='font-weight:normal'> Renting, leasing or sharing with a neighbor allows
the use of equipment for short periods of time without a large investment.
Consider purchasing pre-filled containers, plugs or pre-planted flats to
eliminate the need for equipment and reduce peak labor needs.
Select equipment that is manufactured with standard
parts. Delays in getting special parts
made to repair a down machine can interrupt a production schedule. Standard
parts such as belts, drive chain, pulleys and sprockets can frequently be found
Workstation design. A
workstation is an area where an employee does a series of repetitive tasks such
as transplanting, potting or preparing plants for shipping. The layout of this
area can have a large influence on efficiency. A good layout, where everything
is within easy reach, can decrease needed labor by as much as half.
A good transplanting rate for 48-cell flats is 20-25 flats
per hour. Based on an $8 per hour labor cost, the cost of transplanting 10
flats per hour is $0.80 per flat, 15 flats is $0.53, 20 flats is $0.40 and 25
flats is $0.32.
The top of the table should be at elbow height. Adjustment
should be provided for different-height workers. It is best to provide for both
standing and sitting positions as greater efficiency is achieved when workers
The reach from the normal armrest position to get materials
should be limited to a 24-inch radius to the side and front for women and 27
inches for men. Á The work area is best if within 16-24 inches of the
resting elbow position.
A workstation space of 3 x 3 feet is adequate for most
operations. Space to the rear and sides can hold pre-filled containers, a cart
for placing transplanted containers and movement of the worker. Adequate
lighting of 40-60 foot-candles over the work area will increase productivity
and reduce eyestrain. Where multiple stations are employed, a belt conveyor to
the front of the workers will carry the completed containers to an area where
they can be loaded for transport to the growing area.
An alternate workstation is a movable transplanting table
placed in the greenhouse next to the growing area. The table is moved as the
greenhouse is filled. Pre-filled containers can be supplied on pallets near the
Carts and wagons.
The use of carts can speed up handling and reduce labor needs. One person can
push a cart loaded with 40-60 flats from an efficient transplanting area to the
Select a cart that has large wheels. Tire size should be at
least two inches wide and six inches diameter for use on paved floors and 2 3/4
inches wide and 10 inches diameter for use on unpaved areas. One that has fixed
casters at the center of the cart with a swivel caster at the center of each
end will allow the cart to be turned within its own length.
The cart shelves should be made of a lightweight material
that is strong enough to carry the load without sagging. A smooth metal or
plywood shelf allows easier loading than a wire mesh material. Shelves should
be removable and adjustable for different-size plants.
There are many types and styles of wagons for greenhouse
use. Most have pneumatic tires for transport over unpaved surfaces. The
standard wagon has a fixed rear axle and pivoting front axle on a fifth wheel.
Where wagons will be used in tandem in narrow aisles, select a tracking design
where both axles are connected together and one wagon will follow in the tracks
of the other.
When the distance between the work area and the greenhouse
is greater than 200 feet, carts and wagons should be pulled in tandem in
multiple units to save time. An electric cart or garden tractor can provide the
alternative to carts is a trolley conveyor. The system consists of a tubular or
angle track suspended from the greenhouse or headhouse frame and a
trolley-mounted rack that is pushed along manually. Suspending the track over
the benches and plants means that no additional aisle space is needed. Curved
sections of track carry the cart around corners. Switches can be located
anywhere in the system to allow transfer from one track to another.
The rack should be designed with removable shelves for
different-size plants and should hold from 20-40 flats at one time. Several
racks can be connected together for movement over long runs. Cost of the system
is about $3-5 per linear foot.
Growers are very ingenious when it comes to adapting
existing machines or building new devices to make their job easier. Here are a
few examples I have seen over the years.
Attaching two short-belt conveyors together side by side in an X configuration
makes a pot or flat filler. One conveyor is fitted with a hopper at the lower
end that holds about a bale of growing mix and a shoot at the top end to direct
the mix to a platform below that supports the container. Excess material falls
into a containment that drops it onto the second conveyor that carries it back
to the hopper. Each conveyor has a separate motor. The speed of the conveyors
can be controlled by the size of the pulleys used.
This can be made using two or three fan-type nozzles attached to a piece of PVC
or metal pipe and suspended over a chain or roller conveyor. Water is supplied
to a solenoid valve that controls the water. A lever-type microswitch activates
a 24-volt solenoid valve that turns the water on whenever a flat or pot is
conveyed under the nozzles. A transformer converts 120-volt electricity to 24
volts to reduce the potential for shock. The excess water can be collected with
a pan and piped to a drain, or the unit can be placed directly over the drain
in the floor.
Plant carriers. A
simple pot carrier can be made by welding lightweight, 3/4-inch aluminum
Á or steel square tubing perpendicular to a piece of 3/4- x 3/4-inch
angle iron and spaced just far enough apart to catch the rim of the pots. The
length of the tubing is slightly less than a multiple of the diameter of the
number of pots carried in each slot. A piece of 1-inch conduit bent into a
“U” and welded to the angle forms a handle. This concept can be
adapted to almost any pot size or shape.
Tractor carry. This
box, welded from angle iron and sheet steel, can be designed to fit any
tractor. It is attached to the 3-point hitch on the tractor so it can be
lowered to load materials such as flats, bales or boxes and then raised for
Plastic roll support.
Generally, the easiest way to apply plastic to a hoophouse is to support the
roll above the peak of the greenhouse at one end and pull the leading edge the
length of the greenhouse before unfolding it over the frame. A frame,
fabricated from steel angle or channel can be attached to a bucket loader. It
should be wide enough to fit the length of the poly roll. The roll is supported
by wood- or metal-bearing blocks and a steel pipe shaft.
The smaller grower with limited resources has many opportunities to reduce labor input without purchasing expensive equipment. A good understanding of the basic principles that affect labor usage and the adaptation of low-cost purchased or home-built equipment will make operations more efficient.